MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL
POSITIONAL STRENGTH OVERVIEW BY POSITIONS
01/10/1912
 
CATCHERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
New York Giants Jack Meyers 1st Grover Hartley 3rd 1st
New York Highlanders Roger Bresnahan 2nd Hank Severeid 2nd 2nd
St. Louis Cardinals Jimmy Archer 3rd 6th(tied) 4th
Detroit Tigers Tex Erwin 4th 6th(tied) 5th
Pittsburgh Pirates Gervasio Gonzalez 5th 6th(tied) 6th
Cincinnati Reds Tommy Clarke 6th 6th(tied) 7th
Philadelphia Athletics Ted Easterly 7th Steve O'Neill 1st 3rd
Chicago Cubs Johnny Kling 8th 6th(tied) 9th
Boston Red Sox Hick Cady 9th 6th(tied) 10th
Philadelphia Phillies Louis Santop 10th Dick Cotter 5th 8th
Brooklyn Dodgers Otto Miller 11th 6th(tied) 12th
Chicago White Sox Ray Schalk 12th Wally Mayer 4th 11th
St. Louis Browns William Tenny 13th 6th(tied) 13th
Washington Senators Bruno Block 14th 6th(tied) 14th
Boston Braves Bill Rariden 15th 6th(tied) 15th
Cleveland Naps Gus Fisher 16th 6th(tied) 16th
FIRST BASEMEN
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Detroit Tigers Sam Crawford 1st 3rd(tied) 2nd
St. Louis Cardinals Ed Konetchy 2nd 3rd(tied) 3rd
Brooklyn Dodgers Jake Daubert 3rd 3rd(tied) 4th
Philadelphia Athletics Stuffy McInnis 4th 3rd(tied) 5th
New York Giants Fred Merkle 5th Gene Paulette 1st 1st
St. Louis Browns Jake Stahl 6th 3rd(tied) 6th
Boston Red Sox Harry Wolter 7th 3rd(tied) 8th
Cincinnati Reds Dick Hoblitzel 8th 3rd(tied) 9th
Chicago Cubs Fred Luderus 9th 3rd(tied) 10th
Pittsburgh Pirates Dots Miller 10th Mickey Keliher 2nd 7th
Chicago White Sox Chick Gandil 11th 3rd(tied) 11th
Washington Senators Jack Lelivelt 12th 3rd(tied) 12th
New York Highlanders Bill Pettus 13th 3rd(tied) 13th
Philadelphia Phillies Solly Hofman 14th 3rd(tied) 14th
Cleveland Naps George Stovall 15th 3rd(tied) 15th
Boston Braves Tracy Baker 16th 3rd(tied) 16th
SECOND BASEMEN
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Philadelphia Athletics Eddie Collins 1st 5th(tied) 1st
New York Giants Larry Doyle 2nd 5th(tied) 2nd
Cleveland Naps Nap Lajoie 3rd 5th(tied) 3rd
Boston Red Sox Larry Gardner 4th 5th(tied) 4th
Chicago Cubs Johnny Evers 5th 5th(tied) 5th
Cincinnati Reds Grant Johnson 6th 5th(tied) 8th
Brooklyn Dodgers John Hummel 7th 5th(tied) 9th
St. Louis Browns Del Pratt 8th 5th(tied) 10th
New York Highlanders Frank LaPorte 9th Johnny Priest 4th 6th
St. Louis Cardinals Heinie Wagner 10th 5th(tied) 12th
Pittsburgh Pirates Alex McCarthy 11th 5th(tied) 14th
Chicago White Sox Ping Bodie 12th Marty Berghammer 2nd 11th
Detroit Tigers Otto Knabe 13th Guy Tutwiler 3rd 13th
Boston Braves Art Butler 14th Art Butler 1st 7th
Philadelphia Phillies Arnold Hauser 15th 5th(tied) 15th
Washington Senators Bill Cunningham 16th 5th(tied) 16th
THIRD BASEMEN
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Philadelphia Athletics Frank Baker 1st 4th(tied) 1st
Chicago Cubs Heinie Zimmerman 2nd 4th(tied) 2nd
Boston Braves Hans Lobert 3rd 4th(tied) 4th
New York Giants Buck Herzog 4th 4th(tied) 6th
Brooklyn Dodgers Red Smith 5th 4th(tied) 7th
Pittsburgh Pirates Jim Viox 6th 4th(tied) 9th
St. Louis Cardinals Bobby Byrne 7th Wally Smith 1st 3rd
Boston Red Sox Harry Lord 8th Hal Janvrin 2nd 5th
Cleveland Naps Morrie Rath 9th 4th(tied) 10th
Chicago White Sox Mike Mowrey 10th 4th(tied) 11th
Detroit Tigers Kid Elberfeld 11th 4th(tied) 12th
New York Highlanders Todd Allen 12th 4th(tied) 13th
Washington Senators Roy Hartzell 13th 4th(tied) 14th
Cincinnati Reds Bill Hinchman 14th Rafael Almeida 3rd 8th
St. Louis Browns Art Phelan 15th 4th(tied) 15th
Philadelphia Phillies John Dodge 16th 4th(tied) 16th
SHORTSTOPS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Pittsburgh Pirates Honus Wagner 1st 4th(tied) 1st
Chicago Cubs Joe Tinker 2nd 4th(tied) 3rd
New York Giants Art Fletcher 3rd 4th(tied) 4th
Philadelphia Phillies John Henry Lloyd 4th 4th(tied) 5th
Cincinnati Reds Tom Downey 5th Jimmy Esmond 1st 2nd
Philadelphia Athletics Jack Barry 6th 4th(tied) 6th
New York Highlanders Eddie Foster 7th 4th(tied) 7th
Detroit Tigers Donie Bush 8th 4th(tied) 8th
Cleveland Naps Ray Chapman 9th 4th(tied) 9th
Boston Braves Rabbit Maranville 10th 4th(tied) 10th
Brooklyn Dodgers Bert Tooley 11th 4th(tied) 13th
St. Louis Cardinals Ashes Jackson 12th Milt Reed 3rd 11th
Chicago White Sox Buck Weaver 13th 4th(tied) 14th
Washington Senators Alfredo Cabrera 14th 4th(tied) 15th
St. Louis Browns George McBride 15th Ed Hallinan 2nd 12th
Boston Red Sox Marty Krug 16th 4th(tied) 16th
LEFT FIELDERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Philadelphia Phillies Sherry Magee 1st 4th(tied) 2nd
Pittsburgh Pirates Beals Becker 2nd 4th(tied) 4th
Cleveland Naps John Titus 3rd 4th(tied) 5th
Brooklyn Dodgers Zack Wheat 4th 4th(tied) 6th
Cincinnati Reds Dode Paskert 5th Joe Burns 3rd 3rd
Philadelphia Athletics Amos Strunk 6th 4th(tied) 8th
Chicago Cubs Jimmy Sheckard 7th 4th(tied) 9th
New York Highlanders Birdie Cree 8th Mike Fitzgerald 1st 1st
New York Giants Fred Snodgrass 9th 4th(tied) 10th
Chicago White Sox Max Carey 10th 4th(tied) 11th
Boston Red Sox Harry Hooper 11th Joe Riggert 2nd 7th
Boston Braves Rube Oldring 12th 4th(tied) 12th
Detroit Tigers Jay Kirke 13th 4th(tied) 13th
St. Louis Cardinals Rube Ellis 14th 4th(tied) 14th
St. Louis Browns Pete Compton 15th 4th(tied) 15th
Washington Senators Howie Shanks 16th 4th(tied) 16th
CENTER FIELDERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Detroit Tigers Ty Cobb 1st Biff Schaller 4th 1st
Boston Red Sox Tris Speaker 2nd 6th(tied) 2nd
Boston Braves Johnny Bates 3rd 6th(tied) 4th
New York Giants Mike Donlin 4th 6th(tied) 5th
Washington Senators Clyde Milan 5th 6th(tied) 6th
Pittsburgh Pirates Spottswood Poles 6th 6th(tied) 10th
St. Louis Cardinals Red Murray 7th Jim Clark 5th 9th
Chicago White Sox Shano Collins 8th Jimmy Johnston 2nd 3rd
Brooklyn Dodgers Casey Stengel 9th 6th(tied) 11th
Philadelphia Phillies Pete Hill 10th 6th(tied) 12th
St. Louis Browns Burt Shotton 11th 6th(tied) 13th
Cincinnati Reds Armando Marsans 12th Hy Myers 3rd 7th
New York Highlanders Vin Campbell 13th 6th(tied) 14th
Philadelphia Athletics Herbie Moran 14th 6th(tied) 15th
Chicago Cubs Ashby Dunbar 15th 6th(tied) 16th
Cleveland Naps Buddy Ryan 16th Tim Hendryx 1st 8th
RIGHT FIELDERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Cleveland Naps Joe Jackson 1st 4th(tied) 1st
Philadelphia Athletics Danny Murphy 2nd Chester Emerson 3rd 3rd
Chicago Cubs Frank Schulte 3rd 4th(tied) 4th
Pittsburgh Pirates Owen Wilson 4th 4th(tied) 5th
Boston Red Sox Gavvy Cravath 5th 4th(tied) 6th
St. Louis Browns Hurley McNair 6th 4th(tied) 7th
New York Giants Steve Evans 7th 4th(tied) 8th
Chicago White Sox Danny Moeller 8th Frank Gilhooley 1st 2nd
Cincinnati Reds Mike Mitchell 9th 4th(tied) 9th
Detroit Tigers Hub Northen 10th 4th(tied) 10th
Brooklyn Dodgers Jim Delahanty 11th 4th(tied) 11th
New York Highlanders Guy Zinn 12th 4th(tied) 12th
Boston Braves Eustaquio Pedroso 13th 4th(tied) 13th
Philadelphia Phillies Jimmy Walsh 14th 4th(tied) 15th
Washington Senators Davy Jones 15th 4th(tied) 16th
St. Louis Cardinals Andrew Payne 16th Denney Wilie 2nd 14th
STARTING PITCHERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Washington Senators Walter Johnson 1st Carl Cashion 5th 1st
New York Giants Christy Mathewson 2nd 8th(tied) 4th
Boston Red Sox Joe Wood 3rd Marty McHale 6th 2nd
Chicago White Sox Ed Walsh 4th 8th(tied) 6th
Philadelphia Athletics Charles Bender 5th Boardwalk Brown 3rd 5th
Detroit Tigers Eddie Cicotte 6th Wiley Taylor 7th 7th
New York Highlanders Joe Williams 7th 8th(tied) 10th
Cleveland Naps Cy Falkenberg 8th Earl Yingling 4th 8th
Pittsburgh Pirates Claude Hendrix 9th Hank Robinson 2nd 9th
St. Louis Cardinals Babe Adams 10th 8th(tied) 11th
Philadelphia Phillies Grover Cleveland Alexander 11th 8th(tied) 12th
Chicago Cubs Mordecai Brown 12th 8th(tied) 13th
Cincinnati Reds Jack Quinn 13th 8th(tied) 14th
Brooklyn Dodgers Nap Rucker 14th 8th(tied) 15th
St. Louis Browns Carl Weilman 15th Marc Hall 1st 3rd
Boston Braves Hub Perdue 16th 8th(tied) 16th
RELIEVERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
New York Giants Dick Rudolph 1st Jose Junco 11th(tied) 5th
Pittsburgh Pirates Wilbur Cooper 2nd Sherry Smith 5th 1st
Chicago White Sox George Mogridge 3rd George Mogridge 10th 7th
Philadelphia Athletics Joe Bush 4th Dave Danforth 7th(tied) 3rd
Philadelphia Phillies Erskine Mayer 5th Toots Shultz 15th 10th
Washington Senators Charlie Becker 6th Carl Cashion 11th(tied) 9th
St. Louis Browns Curly Brown 7th Jeff Pfeffer 3rd 4th
Brooklyn Dodgers Sandy Burk 8th Raleigh Aitchison 7th(tied) 8th
Chicago Cubs Fred Toney 9th Fred Toney 4th 6th
St. Louis Cardinals Gene Woodburn 10th Pete Standridge 1st 2nd
Cleveland Naps Jim Baskette 11th Bill James 14th 14th
Boston Braves Brad Hogg 12th Brad Hogg 7th(tied) 11th
Detroit Tigers Tex Covington 13th Pug Cavet 6th 12th
New York Highlanders Chet Hoff 14th Chet Hoff 2nd 13th
Cincinnati Reds Dixie Davis 15th 16th 16th
Boston Red Sox Ben Hunt 16th Marty McHale 13th 15th
CLOSERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
New York Highlanders Ray Fisher 1st Chet Hoff 4th 1st
New York Giants Dick Rudolph 2nd Jose Junco 12th(tied) 12th
Chicago White Sox George Mogridge 3rd George Mogridge 11th 11th
Pittsburgh Pirates Wilbur Cooper 4th Sherry Smith 7th 2nd
Philadelphia Phillies Eppa Rixey 5th Toots Shultz 15th 15th
Philadelphia Athletics Joe Bush 6th Dave Danforth 5th 3rd
Boston Red Sox Bill Lindsay 7th Marty McHale 14th 13th
Cincinnati Reds Marty O'Toole 8th 16th 16th
Chicago Cubs Tom Hughes 9th (tied) Fred Toney 6th 5th
Detroit Tigers George Mullin 9th (tied) Pug Cavet 3rd 4th
Washington Senators Dixie Walker 11th Carl Cashion 12th(tied) 14th
St. Louis Browns Curly Brown 12th Jeff Pfeffer 2nd 6th
Cleveland Naps Otto Hess 13th Earl Yingling 8th(tied) 7th
Boston Braves Jose Acosta 14th Brad Hogg 8th(tied) 9th
Brooklyn Dodgers Elmer Knetzer 15th Raleigh Aitchison 8th(tied) 10th
St. Louis Cardinals Johnny Taylor 16th Pete Standridge 1st 8th
Friday, May 16th , 2025 - OOTP Baseball 25.11 Build 104