The final power rankings from the previous All Time Greats replay are below. A draft, in reverse order of the power rankings will take place prior to the replay of season this replay where 186 NeL players will be added to the MLB clubs. Note out of the 186 free agents the following 80 players were selected to MLB rosters:
- NYA – Howard Easterling 3B
- SDP – Charlie Blackwell RF
- CLE – Joe Greene C, Sam Bankhead SS, Al Smith* LF
- ATL – Sam Crawford SP
- OAK – Bill Holland SP, Mule Suttles DH
- PIT – Sam Streeter SP
- MIL – Leon Day SP, Walter Cannady SS, Alex Radcliff 3B
- SEA – Jud Wilson , Jimmie Lyons LF
- PHI – Judy Johnson
- KCR – Biz Mackey C, Booker McDaniel SP
- CHC – Roosevelt Davis SP
- LAD – Roy Campanella* C
- HOU – Bonnie Serrell 2B, Andy Porter SP, Barney Brown RP, Clarence Palm C
- BOS – Pete Hill CF, Bill Gatewood SP
- TOR – Hurley McNair LF, Candy Jim Tayler 3B
- SFN – Monte Irvin* CF
- NYN – Hilton Smith SP, Bill Drake SP, Fats Jenkins LF
- STL – Dobie Moore SS, Ray Brown SP
- DET – Andy Cooper SP
- CWS – George Scales 2B, Dick Whitworth SP
- CIN – John Beckwith SS, Satchel Paige SP, Max Manning SP, Chaney White CF
- MIA – Dick Lundy SS, Turkey Stearnes CF, Louis Santop C, Buster Clarkson SS, Dave Malarcher 3B
- WSN – Martin Dihigo SP, Wilson Redus LF, Henry McHenry SP, Jim Brown 1B, Phil Cockrell SP
- TBR – John Henry Lloyd SS, Cristobal Torriente DF, George Carr 1B, William Bell SP
- BAL – Webster McDonald SP, Clint Thomas LF
- ARI – Willie Wells DH, Bill Foster SP, Jose Mendez SP, Red Ryan SP, Bruce Petway C, Wild Bill Wright RF
- MIN – Oscar Charleston CF, Bingo DeMoss 2B, Josh Gibson C, Ted Trent SP, Roy Welmaker SP
- LAA – Willard Brown CF, Dave Brown SP, Roy Partlow SP
- TEX – Bullet Rogan LF/SP, Rube Curry SP, Buck O’Neil 1B, Ray Dandridge 3B, Newt Joseph DH
- COL – Edgar Wesley DH, Dan Kennard C, Dick Redding SP, Juan Padron SP, Nip Winters SP, Bill Byrd SP
